The Wall Street Journal ran an article in its Life & Style section a few weeks back called, “Man vs. God.” They had commissioned Karen Armstrong and Richard Dawkins to address the question, Where does evolution leave God? You can read the article here
If you’re familiar with outspoken atheist, Richard Dawkins, you won’t be surprised at his take. Evolution is. God isn’t. End of story.
Karen Armstrong’s response, though, was more artistic. She spoke of two complementary ways of arriving at truth, which the Greeks called mythos and logos. Both were recognized by scholars as legitimate. Logos was reason, logic, intellect. But logos alone couldn’t speak to the deep question human beings ask like, What is the meaning of life? and, Why do bad things happen to good people? For that, she said, people turned to mythos – stories, regardless of whether or not they were true, that helped us make sense out of the difficulties of life. They were therapeutic. We could think of them as an early form of psychology. Here’s what she said:
“Religion was not supposed to provide explanations that lay within the competence of reason but to help us live creatively with realities for which there are no easy solutions and find an interior haven of peace; today, however, many have opted for unsustainable certainty instead. But can we respond religiously to evolutionary theory? Can we use it to recover a more authentic notion of God?
“Darwin made it clear [that] we cannot regard God simply as a divine personality, who single-handedly created the world. This could direct our attention away from the idols of certainty and back to the ‘God beyond God.’ The best theology is a spiritual exercise, akin to poetry.”
Here’s how I understand what she’s saying: Not only is the truth of any religious story irrelevant, it is incorrect to believe any account concerning God as objectively true. To do so is to construct an idol of certainty. How do we know that? Because of the certainty of Darwinian Evolution.
Her response, at bottom, isn’t very different from the atheist’s. Evolution is. God isn’t. But some of us like to imagine that he is.
The frontrunner in “Man vs. God” according to the Wall Street Journal appears to be unanimous: Man. I’d love to have the platform of the Wall Street Journal, but since I don’t, I’ll just toss out my piece here: God is.
I suggest a third way of knowing truth – revelation. Because if there is a God, he can reveal himself if he so chooses. I like the ideas of mythos and logos. Some people come to believe in God through the portal of mythos. Rituals, stories, and artistic expressions can communicate to the soul in ways words can’t. Others come to know God through the portal of logos. Long time atheist intellectual, Antony Flew renounced his atheism a few years ago after seeing the complex language of DNA. “Intelligence must have been involved,” he said.
But revelation is a whole new realm, and my personal opinion is it only comes to those who want to know. “You will seek me and find me when you seek me with all your heart,” God said. The real question is, Do you want to know?
For all my friends out there who do believe, I’d love to hear how you came to that place. Did it start through mythos? logos? Did God later reveal himself to you in a supernatural way? I suspect there are some great stories that are well worth being told. Here’s a platform. Would you tell it? Or if you don’t want it posted, send it to me in an email.
I believe the winner of Man vs. God will ultimately be God. What do you think?
The Housing Boom and Bust
by Thomas Sowell, Economist Extraordinaire
A straightforward case study that should be required reading for American voters, political science students, and anyone who supports government interventions into business “for the good of society.” In The Housing Boom and Bust, Sowell analyzes the housing boom which peaked in 2005, and the collapse which followed shortly thereafter.
Here’s the chain of events, as he presents them:
(1) Beginning in the 1970’s land use restrictions were enacted in certain areas, for example coastal California, Arizona, and a few others. This reduced the amount of developable land which led to higher housing costs in those areas.
(2) Citing “skyrocketing” housing costs and the noble goal of affordable housing for all, politicians began pressuring, bullying, and at times forcing banks to lower lending standards so more buyers could obtain a mortgage. At the same time, HUD began charging banks with discrimination for denying minority applicants, further squeezing high risk loans out of mortgage lenders.
(3) Economists who warned of the risk of a future collapse were ignored, and regulators who uncovered “irregularities” were silenced.
(4) Borrowers began lagging in payments, home values which had been falsely inflated began to decline, and by 2006, the house of cards was beginning to implode.
(5) Politicians, some of whom personally enacted the policies that created the boom and bust, blamed Wall Street, banks, political opponents, anyone and anything except the actual cause which was government intervention into banking.
(6) In October of 2008, the federal government began spending taxpayer dollars and in exorbitant amounts and further intervening into the business realm to “save” the economy.
The case study demonstrates how political posturing, policies, and legislation, whether well-meaning or not, are the biggest cause of the mess our economy is in now. Sowell evenly criticizes Republicans and Democrats, so you won’t find a single partisan argument here, just a smart man hammering facts and drawing lines from causes to effects. It’s a book for citizens.
Whether you fear government takeover, or believe in the power of government to solve problems, check him out. Then come back her and tell me about it.
I’ll never forget the day. Who could? The events of September 11th 2001 drove home to me a few points:
(1) We live in an unstable and dangerous world. Some people in it are bent on destruction.
(2) I’ve taken safety and relative security for granted. Life can end for me or you at any time.
(3) I’ve neglected to tell people I love and value that I love and value them.
(4) Coming to terms with God and the ultimate questions of life matters.
What did September 11th teach you?
I’m blowing 16 years of dust off my computer programming skills and attempting to get me a blog up and running. How am I doing so far?